Refine
Year of Publication
Document Type
- Report (19)
- Part of a Book (14)
- Peer-Reviewed Article (10)
- Contribution to Periodical (4)
- Working Paper (4)
- Conference Object (3)
- Doctoral Thesis (1)
Angesichts der drängenden Herausforderungen unserer Zeit erwarten große Teile der Öffentlichkeit und Politik eine engagierte Wissenschaft, die sich aktiv an der Lösung ökologischer, ökonomischer und sozialer Probleme beteiligt. Diese Erwartungshaltung hat dazu beigetragen, Diskussionen über eine "third mission" der Wissenschaft aufzuwerfen. Damit verbunden sind Fragen zu gesellschaftlichem Engagement und Distanz zur Politik in Forschung und Lehre, mit denen sich bereits der amerikanische Wissenschaftssoziologe Robert K. Merton in den 30er Jahren des vergangenen Jahrhunderts beschäftigte und die ihn dazu bewogen, ein Ethos der Wissenschaft zu postulieren. (...)
Vor dem Hintergrund der Traumatisierung der Wissenschaft durch den Nationalsozialismus und seine dramatischen Folgen stellt sich heute nach wie vor die Frage, ob - und wenn ja wie - Forschung und Lehre gegen politische Intervention und Pervertierung immunisiert werden können. Gibt es überhaupt so etwas wie "reine Wissenschaft" und wie lässt sich diese abgrenzen? Brauchen wir ein Wissenschaftsethos oder gibt es dazu Alternativen?
Im Folgenden versuchen wir uns diesen Fragen zu nähern. Wir sind weder Wissenschaftssoziologen noch Wissenschaftshistoriker und werden deshalb nur sehr kursorisch auf die entsprechenden Forschungen verweisen. Wir nähern uns den Fragen zum einen aus der Perspektive der angewandten Nachhaltigkeitsforschung und zum anderen mit einem wissenschaftsphilosophischen und erkenntnistheoretischen Hintergrund. Unsere Kritik an Mertons Ansatz hat daher sowohl einen explizit praktischen als auch philosophischen Zugang.
Wasting food, wasting resources : potential environmental savings through food waste reductions
(2018)
Food is needed to maintain our physical integrity and therefore meets a most basic human need. The food sector got in the focus of environmental policy, because of its environmental implications and its inefficiency in terms of the amount of food lost along the value chain. The European Commission (EC) flagged the food waste issue a few years ago and adopted since then a series of policies that partially address the problem. Among these, the Resource Efficiency Roadmap set the aspirational goal of reducing the resource inputs in the food chain by 20% and halving the disposal of edible food waste by 2020. Focusing on consumer food waste, we tested what a reduction following the Roadmap's food waste target would imply for four environmental categories in EU28 (European Union 28 Member States): greenhouse gas emissions, land use, blue water consumption, and material use. Compared to the 2011 levels, reaching the target would lead to 2% to 7% reductions of the total footprint depending on the environmental category. This equals a 10% to 11% decrease in inputs in the food value chain (i.e., around half of the resource use reductions targeted). The vast majority of potential gains are related to households, rather than the food-related services. Most likely, the 2020 target will not be met, since there is insufficient action both at Member State and European levels. The Sustainable Development Goals provide a new milestone for reducing edible food waste, but Europe needs to rise up to the challenge of decreasing its per capita food waste generation by 50% by 2030.
A future-oriented and sustainable "Leasing Society" is based on a combination of new and innovative serviceoriented business models, changed product and material ownership structures, increased and improved eco-design efforts, and reverse logistic structures. Together these elements have the potential to change the relationship between producers and consumers, and thereby create a new incentive structure in the economy regarding the use and re-use of resources. While the consumer in a leasing society buys a service (instead of a product), the producer in a leasing society retains the ownership of the product (instead of selling it) and sells the service of using the product. This creates producer incentives to re-use, remanufacture, and recycle products and materials and could become a cornerstone of the circular economy, depending on how the leasing society is implemented. While a predominantly positive picture of the success of a leasing society model and related business cases emerges from the bigger part of the available literature, this paper argues that the resource efficiency of respective business cases is highly dependent on the specific business case design. This paper develops a more cautious and differentiated definition of the leasing society by discussing relevant mechanisms and success factors of leasing society business cases. The leasing society is discussed from a micro business-oriented and a macro environment-oriented perspective complemented by a discussion of conditions for successful business models that reduce environmental impacts and resource footprints.
An der Schwelle zum 21. Jahrhundert steht die Umweltpolitik in Europa vor großen Herausforderungen. Es gilt den hohen Anspruch des Amsterdamer Vertrages umzusetzen, der eine Integration von Umwelt-, Wirtschafts- und Sozialpolitik vorsieht. Wenn dies der Umweltpolitik in Europa bis zur Jahrtausendwende gelingt, wird sie sich somit zu einer Politik der Nachhaltigkeit weiterentwickeln. Andernfalls droht Umweltpolitik wieder in den Status einer zweitrangigen Sektorpolitik zurückzufallen. In dieser Studie wird versucht, dieser drohenden Entwicklung entgegenzutreten. Ausgehend von einer Beschreibung der Ausgangslage der Umweltpolitik in der Europäischen Union (Kap. 2) werden anschließend mögliche Ziele einer weiterentwickelten Umwelt- bzw. Nachhaltigkeitspolitik erörtert. Eine besondere Bedeutung kommt hierbei den Indikatoren zu, anhand derer die Erreichung von Nachhaltigkeit gemessen werden kann (Kap. 3). In der Folge werden Bedingungen und Möglichkeiten einer Umsetzung ökologischer Ziele auf europäischer Ebene geprüft. Zu diesem Zweck werden zunächst die Wirkungen ökologischer Strategien auf ökonomische und soziale Systeme umrissen; danach werden einige mögliche Maßnahmen und Prioritäten für die Ressorts vorgeschlagen, in denen laut Beschluß der Europäischen Räte von Cardiff und Wien die Integration vorrangig umgesetzt werden soll (Kap. 4). Schließlich werden dem Europäischen Rat in Helsinki strategische Ziele vorgeschlagen und ein Formulierungsvorschlag für die Schlußfolgerungen der finnischen Präsidentschaft gemacht (Kap. 5), um so die Integration von Umweltbelangen in dem Sinne voranzubringen, der in den Kapiteln 3 und 4 beschrieben wird.
Die Autoren fassen die Entwicklung Urbaner Produktion und der damit verbundenen ökologischen Beeinträchtigungen zusammen. Vor dem Hintergrund einschlägiger Forschung werden Methoden der Quantifizierung ökologischer Wirkungen Urbaner Produktion mit ihren globalisierten Lieferketten dargestellt. Der Artikel schließt mit einer Darstellung möglicher Perspektiven faktenbasierter, partizipativer Planung Urbaner Produktion.
Economic performance of a country is generally being measured through GDP (Gross Domestic Product), a variable that has also become the de facto universal metric for "standards of living". However, GDP does not properly account for social and environmental costs and benefits. It is also difficult to achieve sustainable decision-making aiming at sustainable progress and well-being if welfare is being considered from a purely financial point of view. The study highlights the benefits and some of the shortcomings of GDP. It serves as a helpful and practicable instrument for monetary and fiscal policies. The real problem presumably is that GDP growth is too often confused with (sustainable) welfare growth in people's minds. While there certainly is a correlation between the two, this study shows that this is a highly conditional correlation, void of substantial causality for GDP levels observable in the European Union. In order to be able to assess people's well-being and general sustainable development in the sense of sustainability, an alternative instrument going beyond GDP is necessary. Using so called SWOT analyses, several alternative progress indicators have been assessed in the context of this study. On the one hand it was analysed how far ecological and social factors can be integrated in the GDP measurements. Thereby difficulties arose then trying to monetise these factors. As a further possibility indicators were analysed which are to replace GDP as a whole. The category supplementing GDP seems to be the most realistic and acceptable option for going beyond GDP. Within this approach, GDP is being complemented with additional environmental and/or social information. In order to make this kind of solution feasible the study claims the establishment of an overarching and transparent indicator system for improving economic decision-making in support of sustainable development.
In his essay, the author presents a stock-taking of the debate on Green Deals. The starting point of this personal assessment is a brief outline of the content and impact of a study in which the author and colleagues published a first outline of a "Green New Deal for Europe" as a political response to the 2008 financial crisis. 2008 had been a critical juncture for mainstream economics: however, from the perspective of policy-learning, the period after has been a lost decade. The European Green Deal as presented by the European Commission in 2019 can be perceived as a historic milestone and confirmation of a regime change in mainstream economic policy in which ecological considerations gain in importance. Yet, the Deal suffers from major deficits. In sum, the European Green Deal could be interpreted as an insufficient attempt to take advantage of the rapidly closing windows of opportunity for a peaceful transition towards sustainability. On the eve of a planetary crisis, the governance of economic transitions towards sustainability needs to be improved and accelerated. Reflecting on the 2009 study A Green New Deal for Europe, this essay attempts to draw a few lessons and frugal heuristics for the policy-design of Green Deals.
The green new deal and ecological industry policy : greening of manufacturing and energy generation
(2011)
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) has matured over the past decades and become part of the broader field of sustainability assessment. To strengthen LCA as a tool and eventually increase its usefulness for sustainability decision-making, it is argued that there is a need to expand the ISO LCA framework by integration and connection with other concepts and methods. This paper explores the potential options for deepening and broadening the LCA methodologies beyond the current ISO framework for improved sustainability analysis. By investigating several environmental, economic and social assessment methods, the paper suggests some options for incorporating (parts of) other methods or combining with other methods for broadening and deepening the LCA.
Nachhaltige Regionalpolitik
(2013)
Leasing society : study
(2012)
Although small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) contribute considerably to Germany's carbon emissions, regional savings and cooperative banks - SMEs' most important financiers - hardly consider this aspect in lending to these businesses. However, given Germany's commitment to climate neutrality by 2045, suitable approaches for injecting climate finance into these SME lending processes are greatly required. Against this background, the paper at hand aims to introduce the specific case of regional banks into the debate on green finance and green banking and suggest future research in this context. In discussing the state of research on the peculiarities of regional savings and cooperative banks, we outline the resulting opportunities and limitations for climate impact assessments in SME lending. We argue that while the dual bottom-line orientation of regional banks in Germany precludes them from applying simple positive or negative screenings, their in-depth knowledge about local clients and circumstances enables them to be active and engaging partners for the green transformation of SMEs. Nonetheless, we explain why developing solutions to utilise this knowledge for climate finance by integrating climate impact assessments into routine lending processes remains a particularly challenging task.
In early September 2014, about 4.000 scientists, activists and artists at the 4th International Conference on Degrowth sent out two messages.
1. Industrialized societies will change, either by disaster or by design. Accelerated resource exploitation and climate change can force societies into a transition. Or they swiftly develop new forms of economic, political and social organization which respect the planetary boundaries.
2. "Degrowth" has become a new social movement which translates scientific insights into cultural change, political change and social practice. Hence, the conference itself was an experiment on the potentials and limits of share economy, commoning and sufficiency.
A team of young scholars and activists from different German research institutes and non-govern- mental organisations prepared the conference. The team of the Wuppertal Institute was partly involved in the preperation of the conference. Scientists from all research groups took part in the conference, presenting and discussing project results.
The publication is a collection of contributions of the Wuppertal Institute to the conference and covers pivotal issues of the degrowth-debate: indicator development (Freyling & Schepelmann), working time reduction (Buhl), feminist theory (Biesecker & Winterfeld), and urban transition (Best).
Vor zehn Jahren, schon bald nach dem Beginn der Finanzkrise, setzte weltweit die Erkenntnis ein, dass die eingebrochenen privaten Investitionen mit staatlichen Konjunkturprogrammen kompensiert werden müssten. Die Regierungen der Welt wendeten sich überraschend schnell von den bisher dominanten laissez-faire Ansätzen ab. Weltweit schlug die Stunde von Staatsinterventionen. Unter dem Titel "Green New Deal" und später "Green Growth" katapultierte sich die ökologische Modernisierung der Wirtschaft quasi über Nacht aus der umweltpolitischen Nische heraus in den konjunkturpolitischen Mainstream. Zwar gab und gibt es immer noch Regierungen und internationale Institutionen, die diese ökologische Wende der Konjunkturpolitik nicht nachvollziehen, allerdings dürften sich diese spätestens seit dem Jahr 2009 in der Minderheit befinden. Die Forschung kam mit dem Tempo der Entwicklungen kaum hinterher. Dennoch lassen sich aus den vergangenen zehn Jahren seit der Finanzkrise von 2008 wichtige Erkenntnisse und Faustregeln z. B. für den European Green Deal aber auch für die angekündigten nationalstaatlichen Konjunkturprogramme nach der Coronakrise ableiten. Der Text begründet die These von einer ökologischen Wende der Konjunkturpolitik. Im Anschluss leitet er daraus wichtige Lektionen für den sich anbahnenden European Green Deal als eine wirtschaftspolitische Antwort auf die Coronakrise ab.
This governance brief aims to provide practical examples on how investments in urban infrastructure, clean energy, and energy efficiency can be implemented; and how these are embedded in multi-level governance, experimentation, and policy-learning. It draws on examples from the German energy system transition, which can be understood as a large-scale, real-life laboratory for the governance of a sustainability transition of an entire national energy system. The federal state of North-Rhine Westphalia's experience illustrates the complexity of the governance challenge of implementing low-carbon system transitions.
Northrhine-Westphalia (NRW) is the largest land of the Federal Republic of Germany. Until the 1970ies the Ruhr-area with a population of about 12 million people and a strong coal, steel and chemical industry had been plagued with severe pollution. In the 1970ies environmental protection had emerged on the international and national policy agendas. The federal and regional government launched massive legislative and economic public interventions for cleaning-up rivers, soils and air. As a result, a highly competitive eco-industry emerged. The article outlines main features of ecoindustries, the structural change of the Ruhr area and regional economic cluster policies in support of eco-industries in NRW. It draws conclusions for eco-industry policy developing from end-of-pipe towards integrated preventive approaches.
The article introduces and exemplifies the approach of evidence-based narratives (EBN). The methodology is a product of co-design between policy-making and science, generating robust intelligence for evidence-based policy-making in the Directorate General for Research and Innovation of the European Commission (DG RTD) under the condition of high uncertainty and fragmented evidence. The EBN transdisciplinary approach tackles practical problems of future-oriented policy-making, in this case in the area of programming for research and innovation addressing the Grand Societal Challenge related to climate change and natural resources. Between 2013 and 2018, the EU-funded RECREATE project developed 20 EBNs in a co-development process between scientists and policy-makers. All EBNs are supported with evidence about the underlying innovation system applying the technological innovation systems (TIS) framework. Each TIS analysis features the innovation, its current state of market diffusion and a description of the innovation investment case. Indicators include potential future market sizes, effects on employment and environmental and social benefits. Based on the innovation and TIS function analyses, the EBNs offer policy recommendations. The article ends with a critical discussion of the EBN approach.
This chapter is an excerpt from a study commissioned by the European Parliament, which examines EU subsidies for agriculture, fisheries, transport, energy and regional development. Based on proven methodologies for the identification and assessment of environmentally harmful subsidies, the study assesses the sustainability level of the sectoral policies and makes recommendations for a reform that would contribute to the alignment of the EU budget towards a more sustainable growth. The following sections provide the main findings of one of the largest fields of expenditure within the EU budget, the structural and cohesion policy.
Driving forces of changing environmental pressures from consumption in the European food system
(2020)
The paper provides an integrated assessment of environmental and socio-economic effects arising from final consumption of food products by European households. Direct and indirect effects accumulated along the global supply chain are assessed by applying environmentally extended input-output analysis (EE-IOA). EXIOBASE 3.4 database is used as a source of detailed information on environmental pressures and world input-output transactions of intermediate and final goods and services. An original methodology to produce detailed allocation matrices to link IO data with household expenditure data is presented and applied. The results show a relative decoupling between environmental pressures and consumption over time and shows that European food consumption generates relatively less environmental pressures outside Europe (due to imports) than average European consumption. A methodological framework is defined to analyze the main driving forces by means of a structural decomposition analysis (SDA). The results of the SDA highlight that while technological developments and changes in the mix of consumed food products result in reductions in environmental pressures, this is offset by growth in consumption. The results highlight the importance of directing specific research and policy efforts towards food consumption to support the transition to a more sustainable food system in line with the objectives of the EU Farm to Fork Strategy.
Die gesellschaftlichen Rahmenbedingungen für eine ökologische Wende der EU-Regionalpolitik sind scheinbar ungünstig. Dem Vorsorgeprinzip der Umweltpolitik liegt die Annahme zugrunde, dass man auf bestimmte Tatsachen reagieren muss, weil sonst Schäden entstehen. Nach dem Soziologen Niklas Luhmann entspricht dies jedoch einer allzu einfachen Alltagsvorstellung. Der Ökonom Hans-Jochen Luhmann diagnostiziert hinsichtlich der Wahrnehmung von ökologisch relevanten Informationen eine regelrechte "Blindheit der Gesellschaft". Blockaden bei der Umsetzung von Umweltpolitik scheinen diese Befunde zu bestätigen. Der Planungswissenschaftler Arthur Benz meint in diesem Kontext, dass man bei der Durchsetzung von Planungskontrolle eben nicht mit dem freiwilligen Lernen der Akteure rechnen dürfe. Wie lässt sich unter diesen Bedingungen eine ökologische Wende der Europäischen Regionalpolitik umsetzen? Ist der Planungspessimismus, der sich in Deutschland nach einem Planungsoptimismus der 1970er Jahre durchgesetzt hat, gerechtfertigt? Welchen Wert können zielorientierte Instrumente wie etwa Indikatoren für die Umweltplanung in der Regionalpolitik noch haben? Vor dem Hintergrund gesellschaftlicher Differenzierung beleuchtet der Umweltwissenschaftler Philipp Schepelmann die Probleme, die bei der Anwendung von Umweltindikatoren in der regionalen Wirtschaftsförderung auftauchen. Für seine empirische Untersuchung im Ziel-2 Gebiet der EU-Strukturfonds in Nordrhein-Westfalen entwickelt er in Anlehnung an die soziologische Systemtheorie das Konzept der Resonanz. Resonanz bezeichnet die aktive Reaktion von sozialen Systemen auf Umweltprobleme als Voraussetzung für eine zielorientierte Umweltpolitik. Die Resonanz von Policy-Netzwerken gegenüber Umweltindikatoren kann nachgewiesen und verglichen werden. Am Beispiel der umweltpolitischen Indikatoren des Lissabon-Prozesses der Europäischen Union wird die regionale Resonanz von Indikatoren in verschiedenen Policy-Netzwerken untersucht. Das Ergebnis der Resonanzanalyse ist aus planerischer Sicht überraschend positiv: Es gibt nicht nur Blindheit und Untätigkeit gegenüber ökologischen Herausforderungen; differenzierte Policy-Netzwerke leiten in NRW erfolgreich eine ökologische Wende der EU-Regionalpolitik ein.
Renania del Norte-Westfalia (RNW) es el mayor estado federal (land) de la República Federal de Alemania. Hasta la década de 1970, la región del Rin-Ruhr, con una población de unos 12 millones de habitantes y una potente industria química, del carbón y del acero, se vio afectada por graves problemas de contaminación. En los años setenta, la protección medioambiental apareció en las agendas políticas nacionales e internacionales. Los gobiernos federales y el estatal lanzaron múltiples intervenciones legislativas y económicas para limpiar ríos, suelos y aire. Como resultado, surgió una ecoindustria muy competitiva. En este artículo, se resumen las características de las ecoindustrias y se describe el cambio estructural de la región del Ruhr. Asimismo, centrándose en el mesonivel y empleando los ejemplos de la gestión energética y la gestión municipal de residuos, se destacan los puntos fuertes y los puntos débiles de las políticas económicas regionales de clusters que apoyan las ecoindustrias en RNW.
